When you hear “flavored whiskey,” your mind might jump straight to a certain cinnamon spirit famous for shots. But the category has grown up a lot since then. Today, the best flavored whiskeys are designed for so much more than just a quick party starter. They’re being crafted with quality base spirits and balanced, natural-tasting notes that make them perfect for sipping on their own or as the star ingredient in a creative cocktail. Forget what you think you know. We’re going to show you how versatile these spirits can be, from dessert-inspired sippers to refreshing fruity highballs, and highlight the most popular flavored whiskey bottles that are changing the game.
Key Takeaways
- Start with Flavor, Not Fear: Flavored whiskeys are designed to be approachable and fun, offering a smoother introduction to the world of whiskey if you find traditional spirits a bit too intense.
- Match Your Palate to a Bottle: The easiest way to choose a flavored whiskey is to think about the tastes you already love. Whether it’s dessert, fruit, or spice, there’s a bottle out there that aligns with your preferences, from s’mores to crisp apple.
- Enjoy It Your Way: There are no strict rules for drinking flavored whiskey. Try it neat or on the rocks to appreciate its unique profile, or use it as a simple base for creative cocktails by adding soda, ginger ale, or even a splash in your hot chocolate.
Why Is Everyone Drinking Flavored Whiskey?
It feels like every time you walk down the liquor store aisle, there’s a new, intriguing flavored whiskey on the shelf. From peanut butter to apple cinnamon, the options are exploding, and it’s not just a passing fad. So, what’s behind the massive popularity of these creative spirits?
For starters, flavored whiskeys are incredibly approachable. If you’ve ever found traditional whiskey a bit too intense or overwhelming, you’re not alone. Flavored options offer a smoother, often sweeter, entry point into the world of whiskey. They act as a perfect bridge for newcomers, making the spirit feel less intimidating and more fun. Many people find them a great choice for getting into whiskey without a harsh bite.
Another huge draw is their versatility. You don’t need to be a master mixologist to enjoy them. They’re delicious sipped neat or over a big ice cube, but they also shine in simple cocktails. Think about adding a splash of s’mores whiskey to your hot chocolate or a honey-flavored one to your iced tea. The possibilities for creating unique blends are endless, encouraging experimentation at home. This creative freedom has captured the attention of both seasoned drinkers looking for something new and casual fans who just want a tasty, easy-to-make drink.
7 Popular Flavored Whiskeys to Add to Your Bar Cart
If you’ve been curious about flavored whiskey, you’ve picked a great time to start exploring. The world of whiskey has expanded far beyond traditional notes of oak and grain, now offering an incredible spectrum of tastes that appeal to all kinds of palates. From sweet and nostalgic to fruity and spicy, there’s a flavored whiskey out there that’s perfect for your next cocktail creation or for sipping on its own. Think of it as a simple way to add a personal touch to your home bar.
Whether you’re a seasoned whiskey aficionado looking for something new or someone who’s just beginning to explore spirits, this list is for you. We’ve gathered seven of the most popular and interesting flavored whiskeys that are consistently winning over fans. These bottles are celebrated for their unique profiles, mixability, and overall fun factor. Get ready to find your next favorite pour.
Mash & Mallow S’Mores Whiskey
Let’s start with a personal favorite that brings a campfire right to your glass. Mash & Mallow S’Mores Whiskey perfectly captures the nostalgic taste of a freshly toasted s’more. From the moment you open the bottle, you get inviting aromas of marshmallow, graham cracker, and a hint of smoke. The flavor delivers on that promise with sweet, charred marshmallow notes balanced by a smooth whiskey finish. At 70 proof, it’s incredibly approachable and fun. It’s fantastic for sipping over ice or as the star ingredient in a creative dessert cocktail. If you want a truly unique spirit, you can buy Mash & Mallow online and have it delivered.
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey
If you love all things peanut butter, Skrewball is a must-try. This whiskey became an instant sensation for a reason—it has a bold, sweet, and unmistakable candied peanut butter flavor with a subtle hint of chocolate. It’s a rich and decadent spirit that feels like a treat in a glass. While it’s delicious on its own, one of the best ways to enjoy it is poured over a scoop of chocolate peanut butter ice cream for an incredible adult dessert. It’s a fan favorite that proves whiskey can be playful and seriously delicious at the same time.
Fireball Cinnamon Whisky
You can’t talk about flavored spirits without mentioning Fireball. This cinnamon whisky is a staple in bars across the country and a go-to for anyone who loves a bit of spicy heat. It delivers a powerful, sweet cinnamon kick that’s surprisingly smooth. While many enjoy it as a chilled shot, it’s also a versatile mixer that adds a warm, spicy dimension to cocktails. Try it in hot apple cider during the fall or mix it with a hard seltzer for a refreshing twist. Its widespread popularity has made it a classic choice for a reason.
Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Honey
From one of the most iconic names in whiskey comes a smooth and sweet offering that’s incredibly easy to drink. Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Honey blends their classic Old No. 7 whiskey with a rich, natural honey liqueur. The result is a mellow spirit with notes of honey, vanilla, and a hint of nuttiness that complements the underlying character of the whiskey. It’s not overly sweet, making it a great choice for sipping on the rocks with a lemon twist. It also works beautifully in simple cocktails, like a whiskey sour or a hot toddy, making it one of the best flavored whiskeys for any occasion.
Crown Royal Apple
For a crisp and refreshing take on flavored whiskey, look no further than Crown Royal Apple. This spirit blends the signature smoothness of Crown Royal’s Canadian whisky with the bright, tart flavor of fresh apples. It’s a vibrant and juicy spirit that’s perfect for creating light and easy-drinking cocktails. Mix it with cranberry juice for a simple “Crownberry Apple” or top it with ginger ale for a bubbly highball. It’s a versatile and popular choice, especially during the warmer months, and a great way to introduce friends to the world of flavored whiskey brands.
Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey
Here’s another fantastic option for peanut butter lovers. Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey offers a rich, creamy, and nutty flavor that tastes just like a spoonful of your favorite spread. It’s incredibly smooth and has a satisfyingly sweet finish that makes it perfect for sipping neat or adding to dessert-inspired drinks. It’s especially good in a boozy milkshake or a peanut butter-themed old fashioned. If you’re looking to experiment with sweet and savory cocktails, this whiskey provides a fun and delicious base to build upon. It’s a standout in the growing category of nutty whiskeys.
Jameson Orange
Jameson Irish Whiskey is known for its exceptional smoothness, and this orange-flavored expression is no exception. Jameson Orange combines the classic triple-distilled whiskey with a natural, zesty orange flavor. It’s bright and citrus-forward without being overpowering, allowing the character of the whiskey to still shine through. This spirit is incredibly refreshing and works well in simple mixed drinks—just add some soda water or lemon-lime soda for a perfect afternoon sipper. It’s a great way to put a fresh, citrusy twist on your favorite whiskey cocktails and a welcome new addition from a beloved brand.
The Hottest Flavors in Whiskey Right Now
If you think flavored whiskey is just a passing trend, think again. The category has exploded with creativity, moving far beyond simple honey or cinnamon infusions. Distillers are now crafting complex, delicious spirits that capture the essence of everything from campfire desserts to fresh-picked fruit. This is great news for anyone who loves a good drink but isn’t necessarily a fan of a straight, traditional whiskey. It’s all about finding a flavor profile that speaks to you.
The beauty of this boom is the sheer variety. Whether you have a serious sweet tooth, prefer something with a spicy kick, or enjoy a bright, fruity cocktail, there’s a flavored whiskey out there for you. These spirits are designed to be approachable and versatile. You can sip them neat, pour them over ice for a simple and satisfying drink, or use them as a base for inventive cocktails. Exploring the different flavor categories is a fun way to discover what you like and expand your home bar beyond the basics. Let’s look at some of the most popular flavor trends taking over the whiskey world.
Sweet and Dessert-Inspired
This is where the fun really begins. Dessert-inspired whiskeys are perfect for anyone with a sweet tooth, offering the comforting flavors of your favorite treats in a glass. Think rich salted caramel, creamy vanilla bean, and of course, the nostalgic taste of toasted s’mores. These whiskeys are fantastic on their own as an after-dinner drink, but they also make incredible cocktails. A salted caramel whiskey, like the one from Duke & Dame, can transform a standard Old Fashioned into something truly special. It’s a category that proves whiskey can be both sophisticated and delightfully sweet.
Fruit-Forward
For a lighter, more refreshing take, fruit-forward whiskeys are leading the charge. These spirits capture the bright, juicy flavors of peaches, apples, cherries, and oranges, making them a perfect match for warmer weather. They mix beautifully into simple highballs with soda or tonic and can add a vibrant twist to classic cocktails like a Whiskey Sour. Some of the most highly-rated flavored whiskeys fall into this category, like Hardhide’s Chilton County Peach Whiskey. Whether you’re making a big batch of punch for a party or just want a simple, refreshing drink on the patio, a fruit-flavored whiskey is an excellent choice.
Spice and Heat
If you like your drinks with a bit of a kick, the world of spiced whiskey has plenty to offer. Cinnamon is the classic choice, delivering a warm, fiery flavor that’s become a staple for shots and holiday drinks. But the category is expanding to include more complex spice blends. You can find whiskeys infused with the festive notes of gingerbread, like Bird Dog Gingerbread Flavored Whiskey, or the warm, autumnal taste of chai. These spirits are ideal for cozying up on a cold night and add incredible depth to warm cocktails like hot toddies or spiked apple cider.
Nutty and Savory
One of the most interesting trends is the rise of nutty and savory whiskeys, with peanut butter leading the way. It might sound unusual, but the combination of rich, roasted peanut flavor with the smoothness of whiskey is a match made in heaven. Brands like Skrewball and Ole Smoky have perfected this profile, creating spirits that are both sweet and savory. These whiskeys are surprisingly versatile—they’re delicious sipped on their own, mixed into a decadent dessert cocktail, or even paired with chocolate liqueurs. It’s a bold flavor that shows just how creative the world of flavored spirits has become.
Taste Test: How Do These Whiskeys Compare?
With so many flavored whiskeys on the shelf, it can be tough to know which bottle to grab. While your personal taste is always the most important factor, a few key things separate a truly great flavored whiskey from one that misses the mark. Think of it like baking—the final product is only as good as the ingredients you start with and how well you combine them.
When you’re trying a new spirit, consider these four elements. They’ll help you understand what you’re tasting and find the whiskeys you’ll genuinely enjoy drinking, whether you’re sipping them straight or mixing them into a cocktail.
Flavor Balance
The best flavored whiskeys strike a perfect harmony between the spirit’s natural character and its added notes. You don’t want a drink that’s so sweet or overpowering that you can’t even taste the whiskey underneath. Instead, look for a blend where the flavors complement each other. For example, the warm vanilla and oak from the barrel should work with, not against, the added fruit, spice, or sweetness. A well-balanced spirit is complex and interesting, inviting you back for another sip to see what other notes you can pick up.
Base Whiskey Quality
You can’t make a great flavored whiskey with a subpar base. The quality of the original spirit is the foundation for the entire drink. A smooth, well-crafted whiskey will provide a rich and satisfying backdrop for any added flavors. When you take a sip, you should still be able to detect the classic characteristics of the whiskey—whether it’s the caramel and char of an American whiskey or the lighter notes of an Irish blend. High-quality unique blends ensure the spirit’s integrity shines through, creating a more enjoyable and authentic experience.
Natural vs. Artificial Flavors
Pay attention to how the whiskey gets its flavor. Does it taste like real, authentic ingredients, or does it have a synthetic, candy-like quality? Some spirits use artificial flavorings that can come across as overly sweet or chemical-tasting. The most memorable flavored whiskeys often use natural extracts and ingredients to achieve their taste. This approach usually results in a more genuine and nuanced flavor profile that feels crafted rather than concocted. When you’re trying to decide, think about whether the flavor reminds you of the real thing, like a freshly toasted marshmallow versus a generic sweetener.
Price and Value
A higher price tag doesn’t always guarantee a better whiskey. There are plenty of fantastic, affordable flavored whiskeys that deliver an incredible experience without breaking the bank. Value is all about what you get for your money. Is the whiskey well-balanced, made with a quality base, and delicious to drink? If so, it’s a great value. Reading expert ratings and reviews can be a huge help here, as they often highlight bottles that offer exceptional quality for their price point, helping you make a smart purchase.
The Best Ways to Enjoy Flavored Whiskey
So you’ve picked out a bottle of flavored whiskey—now for the fun part. One of the best things about these spirits is their versatility. Whether you’re a seasoned whiskey drinker or just starting to explore, there are plenty of ways to enjoy the unique notes of your new favorite bottle. You can keep it simple to savor the spirit’s intended flavor or use it as a creative base to build something entirely new. Forget stuffy rules; the goal is to find what you like best. Here are a few of my favorite ways to drink flavored whiskey.
Neat or On the Rocks
Before you start mixing, I always recommend trying a new flavored whiskey on its own. This gives you a chance to really taste what the distillers created. Pouring it “neat” simply means serving about two ounces of whiskey straight into a glass at room temperature—no ice, no mixers. If you prefer a slight chill that opens up the flavors without too much dilution, try it “on the rocks” (with ice). Sipping a spirit like Mash & Mallow S’mores Whiskey this way lets you appreciate the distinct layers of toasted marshmallow, chocolate, and graham cracker. It’s a complete experience all in one glass.
In Creative Cocktails
This is where you can really let your creativity shine. Flavored whiskeys make an incredible base for all kinds of drinks because they bring so much personality to the party. You can go simple by mixing it with soda, ginger ale, or tonic for a quick and refreshing highball. They also work beautifully in warm drinks, like a hot toddy with an apple or honey-flavored whiskey. For something truly special, try swapping traditional whiskey with a flavored version in a classic recipe. A S’mores Old Fashioned or a Peanut Butter Whiskey Espresso Martini, anyone? The possibilities are endless, so feel free to experiment with your own creative cocktails.
As a Seasonal Treat
Certain flavors just feel right at certain times of the year. A bottle of apple or cinnamon-spiced whiskey is the perfect companion for a crisp autumn evening, especially when mixed into a warm cider. Lighter, fruit-forward whiskeys with notes of peach or orange are fantastic in summery spritzes and iced teas. And a rich, dessert-inspired spirit like s’mores whiskey is a natural fit for cozy winter nights by the fire, but it’s equally at home during a summer bonfire with friends. Flavored whiskeys also make great gifts for holidays and special occasions, offering a unique and thoughtful twist on a classic present.
Paired with Food
Don’t forget that whiskey can be a great partner for food, and flavored varieties open up even more delicious combinations. Think of it like pairing wine. The key is to complement or contrast the flavors. A spicy cinnamon whiskey could stand up to a rich, savory dish like barbecue ribs. A sweet, nutty whiskey is a perfect match for a cheese board featuring aged cheddar and figs. And of course, dessert-inspired whiskeys are a no-brainer for sweet pairings. Try drizzling a little S’mores Whiskey over a bowl of vanilla ice cream or serving it alongside a decadent chocolate lava cake for an unforgettable finish to your meal.
Where to Find the Best Deals on Flavored Whiskey
Finding a new flavored whiskey to love is exciting, but finding it at a great price is even better. A little smart shopping can go a long way, whether you’re stocking your bar cart or just want to try something new without a huge investment. The good news is there are plenty of places to look for a good deal, from your couch to your neighborhood store.
Knowing where and when to shop can help you save money and discover unique spirits you might not have found otherwise. Distilleries often run special promotions directly on their websites, and your local liquor store might have its own sales cycle. It’s all about being a savvy shopper, so you can spend less time hunting for deals and more time enjoying a delicious drink.
Online and Direct from the Distillery
One of the best ways to find a deal is to go straight to the source. Many distilleries sell their products online and often feature exclusive offers you won’t find anywhere else. Sometimes, they need to clear out seasonal inventory, which means you can get amazing craft spirits at a fantastic price. Online retailers also compete to offer great prices and convenient, fast delivery. If you’re ready to try something new, you can often buy our S’Mores Whiskey online and have it shipped right to your door, making it easy to get your hands on unique bottles.
Your Local Liquor Store
Don’t underestimate your local liquor store. It’s a great place to get personalized recommendations and discover new brands. Many stores now offer the best of both worlds, letting you order your favorite flavored whiskeys online for curbside pickup or even local delivery. This gives you the convenience of online shopping with the instant gratification of picking it up the same day. If you prefer to browse in person, you can always use a store locator to find a bottle near you and see what deals are available on the shelf. It’s a great way to support local businesses while exploring new spirits.
Seasonal Sales and Promotions
Timing can be everything when it comes to getting a good deal. Keep an eye out for sales around major holidays and seasonal changes. Flavored whiskeys make for a perfect gift option, especially for occasions like Valentine’s Day or Christmas, and this seasonal demand often leads to special promotions. Retailers are looking to attract shoppers during these busy times, so you’ll frequently find discounts on popular and gift-worthy bottles. Planning your purchases around these events is a simple way to save while trying out new and exciting flavors that are perfect for the season.
So, Which Flavored Whiskey Should You Try First?
With so many creative options out there, picking your first (or next) flavored whiskey can feel a little overwhelming. The best place to start is by thinking about the flavors you already love. Are you a dessert person? Do you prefer something fruity or spicy? Let’s break down some top-rated choices to help you find your perfect match.
For the Sweet Tooth
If your ideal treat involves chocolate, caramel, or anything that reminds you of dessert, you’re in the right place. For a truly nostalgic experience, our very own Mash & Mallow S’Mores Whiskey captures the taste of a campfire classic with notes of toasted marshmallow, rich chocolate, and graham cracker. If you enjoy a sweet and salty combination, Duke & Dame Salted Caramel Whiskey is another fun option. And for something that tastes like a “boozy waffle,” as one review put it, you might enjoy the rich notes in Five Springs Vanilla Maple Infused Bourbon.
For the Nut Butter Fanatic
Peanut butter whiskey has become a massive hit, and for good reason. It’s creamy, savory, and surprisingly versatile. Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey is a popular choice with a distinct candied peanut butter flavor that pairs incredibly well with chocolate desserts. Another highly-rated option is Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey, which brings a smooth, nutty profile that’s fantastic in sweet cocktails or simply sipped on its own. Both are great introductions to this savory and sweet category.
For a Touch of Fruit
If you’re looking for something bright and refreshing, a fruit-infused whiskey is an excellent choice. Hardhide Chilton County Peach Whiskey is a standout, offering a vibrant and juicy peach flavor that can instantly liven up your cocktails. It’s a great way to add a summery twist to a classic whiskey sour or simply enjoy it with some soda water. This style is perfect for drinkers who appreciate a lighter, fruit-forward profile in their spirits.
For Those Who Like It Spicy
Sometimes you want a little warmth and spice in your glass. Cinnamon whiskeys deliver just that, and they’re perfect for sipping on a cool evening. Evan Williams Fire offers a smooth, warm cinnamon flavor without being overwhelmingly sweet, and it’s a very affordable option. It’s a straightforward and satisfying choice that you can enjoy neat, on the rocks, or mixed into a simple cocktail for an extra kick.
For Ultimate Convenience
Let’s be honest, sometimes you just want a delicious drink without any of the work. That’s where ready-to-drink (RTD) cocktails come in. The Jack Daniel’s & Coca-Cola with Vanilla is a perfect example. It takes a classic combination and adds a smooth hint of vanilla, giving you a perfectly mixed, sweet, and easy-drinking option right out of the can. It’s a great choice for picnics, parties, or any time you want a no-fuss cocktail.
Related Articles
- 15 Best Sweet Whiskey Brands for Every Palate
- 10 Best Flavored Whiskeys to Drink Straight
- 9 Best Sweet Flavored Whiskeys to Try Now
Frequently Asked Questions
Is flavored whiskey just for shots or overly sweet drinks? Not at all! While some, like cinnamon whisky, are popular for shots, most flavored whiskeys are crafted for sipping and mixing. Think of them as a great starting point for creative cocktails. You can enjoy a s’mores whiskey on the rocks for a complete dessert-in-a-glass experience or use a fruit-forward one to add a fresh twist to a simple highball with soda water.
I don’t really like the taste of traditional whiskey. Will I like these? There’s a very good chance you will. Flavored whiskeys are a fantastic entry point because they soften the intense, oaky notes that can be a turn-off for some. They offer a smoother, more approachable profile with familiar tastes like peanut butter, apple, or honey. It’s a great way to explore the category without the harsh bite you might associate with straight whiskey.
Are all flavored whiskeys incredibly sweet? That’s a common misconception, but the variety is huge. While dessert-inspired options are certainly sweet, you can also find many that are spicy, fruity, or savory. There are whiskeys with a warm cinnamon kick, a bright citrus zest, or even a rich, nutty profile. The goal is flavor balance, not just sugar, so there’s truly something for every palate.
Can I use flavored whiskey in a classic cocktail recipe? Absolutely, and it’s one of the best ways to experiment. Swapping a traditional whiskey for a flavored one can completely transform a familiar drink. Imagine an Old Fashioned made with salted caramel whiskey or a Whiskey Sour with a splash of peach whiskey. It’s a simple way to put your own signature on a classic recipe without needing a dozen different ingredients.
What’s the best way to try a new flavored whiskey for the first time? I always suggest tasting it neat—just a small pour in a glass with no ice—to get a pure sense of its flavor profile. This lets you appreciate all the different notes the distiller intended. After that, try it over a large ice cube, which will chill the spirit and slightly dilute it, often opening up new aromas and tastes.
